They say New York City has everything. But it doesn’t have a Walmart.
Unions and politicians in the Big Apple have kept the retailer out, but Walmart wants in, and even a hostile City Council probably can’t stop it.
You know how Walmart has those greeters at the door? At a New York City Council meeting Thursday, about 100 people stood outside to offer this salutation to Walmart: “Don’t come in! Not in our communities.”
“One thing about real New Yorkers is that we don’t shut up,” said Valerie Jean, one of those anti-Walmart greeters.
The City Council hearing on the impact of a Walmart store in the Big Apple lasted four long hours. When it came to hating Walmart, the council stacked it deep and sold it cheap.
Councilman Charles Barron, who represents the east New York neighborhood that Walmart has been eyeing, set the tone.
“Don’t even think about coming into east New York,” he said. “We’re desperate for jobs, but we’re not going to take anything. We want jobs with dignity, jobs with integrity, jobs with self-respect.”
Although Barron might vote against a Walmart store, there is a small problem: There isn’t anything to vote on. Walmart has not formally picked a site in New York City. There is no request for a zoning change. And, in fact, it’s unclear who Barron was speaking to, since Walmart refused to show up for the hearing.
Don’t even think about coming into east New York. We’re desperate for jobs, but we’re not going to take anything. We want jobs with dignity, jobs with integrity, jobs with self-respect.
City Councilman Charles Barron
That made Council President Christine Quinn all the more mad.
“Walmart’s absence and refusal to attend sadly only leads me to be further skeptical about them as a company,” she said.
And so the flogging began — with testimony from professors about how Walmart can drive smaller stores out of business, and impassioned pleas from small-business owners worried about the competition, and unions concerned about the low wages. So why didn’t Walmart executives want to show up for their own funeral?
“Well, I didn’t say we weren’t going to be listening,” said Steven Restivo, Walmart’s director of community affairs. He was going to watch a webcast of the hearing from the safety of his computer in New Jersey.
Restivo said the whole event was hypothetical; there’s no project yet. And the hearing ignored the fact that there are dozens of other big-box stores in New York: Target, Costco, Home Depot.
Restivo said customers should make this decision.
“If we open a store, and no one comes, or we open a hiring center and no one applies for a job, we’ll have learned a really important lesson about New York City,” he said. “We just don’t think that’s going to happen.”
Well, Walmart is making sure it isn’t going to happen: Instead of going to the hearing, Walmart bought radio ads talking up the benefits of a megastore. It even flew New York neighborhood leaders down to Bentonville, Ark., where the company has its headquarters.
Charles Fisher, who took the trip, testified at the hearing that he is now 100 percent for Walmart. Fisher said executives there promised plenty of jobs and even money for college.
“If Walmart comes into my community and they lied to me, they won’t be here very long. Believe that. They’ll be running out of New York City,” he said.
In the end, Walmart may be able to sidestep politics altogether. One possible site for it in Brooklyn has already been zoned for big-box stores. In theory, Walmart wouldn’t need anything but the property developer’s permission.
But New York City Council members clearly sent the message that they won’t make it easy.